When did we argue this? Pretty sure I said the character designer, designs characters with input from the production team. "You literally don’t know what character designer have influence over art style" Lol, I've never seen anyone argue with such bad faith. “Character designers they don't just design these characters by themselves.” That showed me how much you know about animation production now stop acting like you know thing when you literally have 0 idea about an art style. You don’t know the in-house animator’s nor freelance animator’s importance for particularly deciding an art style. You have neither watched Selection project by Doga kobo and start giving false acclamation of having same art style. You literally don’t know what character designer have influence over art style neither you don’t know madoka magica had same staff except character deisgner which made changes in art style but your pity excuse of all staffs leaving blandly putting just showed me how knowledgeable you are. For what I said to be wrong or right, you would have to know what the art style of the Anime will be but you don't. All you've done is mention stuff people already know, my comment isn't something that you can say is wrong or right. Shikimori would've benefited from having an art style closer to a Horimiya but they made it look too cartoonish.Īnd yes, you're completely right about the staff.You haven't explained anything, so get down from that pedestal ffs. With regards to your comment about it being dependant on source material, this is when Shikimori is relevant. Round heads, big eyes, cartoonish look to them and so on are all staples of a Doga Kobo Anime. I'm also not sure how you can say 'studio never really fixed on the same art style' when 99% of Doga Kobo Anime have the same artstyle. ĭude, I'm not arguing that they can't change their artstyle or they never have, I literally reference Sing Yesterday for Me in my comment. You can only know when a studio is doing same art style is due to their in-house participation, the freelancers doing a project barely states what art style the anime would look like. Look at the Mappa attack on Titan, idaten deities, Dance dance danseur these all have different art styles.Īs I said studio never really fixed on same art style it depends on the source material they are choosing. Different staff matter, but from looking at the staff working on this, I don't expect any major changes to the style Doga Kobo usually do. I don't particularly like how most of the Characters in Doga Kobo anime have round heads and massive eyes, I would've definitely preferred something similar to what KyoAni or Cloverworks do.Īnd yes, you're completely right about the staff. Yes the animation is usually smooth but the artstyle is what splits people. I'm talking about artstyle not animation, Doga Kobo besides Sing Yesterday for Me all have a similar moe heavy artstyle, even Selection Project. I feel like you completely misunderstood what I said. The staff is same as selection project so judge from that point of view. Even cloverwoeks horimiya wasn’t anything special in terms of animation and you see a different animation for sono doll bisque which was done by different team. Not everything is did by clover works, kyoani and Mappa, studios can significantly change their art style for different anime according to the manga art. It works if your Anime is a CGDCT like a lot of Doga Kobo Anime are, but you also have shows like Shikimori which people don't think it works well in. Their artstyle really embraces the moe in characters, while I think a lot of people would've loved this to have a more 'realistic' artstyle similar to what Cloverworks, KyoAni or MAPPA do. Their artstyle is the problem, not the actual animation quality itself. Overall Doga kobo is a consistent studio when it comes to animation, idk why you taking shikimori as an example lol when the animation is still consistent in it. ![]() It’s Selection project director and the character designer is literally a talented guy ( rent a girlfriend character designer ) Kappe.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |